Equity, equality and need as determinants of pay allocations

Article Properties
Abstract
Cite
Giacobbe‐Miller, Jane K., et al. “Equity, Equality and Need As Determinants of Pay Allocations”. Employee Relations, vol. 19, no. 4, 1997, pp. 309-20, https://doi.org/10.1108/01425459710170031.
Giacobbe‐Miller, J. K., Miller, D. J., & Zhang, W. (1997). Equity, equality and need as determinants of pay allocations. Employee Relations, 19(4), 309-320. https://doi.org/10.1108/01425459710170031
Giacobbe‐Miller JK, Miller DJ, Zhang W. Equity, equality and need as determinants of pay allocations. Employee Relations. 1997;19(4):309-20.
Journal Categories
Social Sciences
Commerce
Business
Social Sciences
Commerce
Business
Personnel management
Employment management
Social Sciences
Economic theory
Demography
Economics as a science
Social Sciences
Industries
Land use
Labor
Labor
Work
Working class
Labor market
Labor supply
Labor demand
Description

How do cultural values influence compensation decisions? This research examines the role of equity, equality, and need as determinants of pay allocations among Chinese and US managers in a role-play scenario. The study reveals distinct differences in distributive justice principles across cultures, highlighting the importance of cultural sensitivity in designing compensation systems. The study involves a role-play in which Chinese and US managers allocate a hypothetical bonus to a work group. The results indicate that Chinese managers prioritize equality, employing equity, equality, and need rules. US managers emphasize equity, utilizing equity and equality rules. Chinese managers also placed greater emphasis on the need rule than did US managers. These findings underscore the importance of considering cultural values when designing pay systems to ensure fairness and motivation across diverse workforces. Understanding the relative importance of equity, equality, and need in different cultures can inform effective compensation strategies that align with employee expectations and promote a positive work environment. Appropriate pay design is essential.

As a publication in Employee Relations, this paper aligns with the journal's focus on workplace dynamics and human resource management. The examination of cultural differences in pay allocation contributes to the journal's exploration of fairness and equity in the workplace. The citations reflect the paper's engagement with existing literature in organizational behavior and cross-cultural management.

Refrences
Citations
Citations Analysis
The first research to cite this article was titled Class and gender influences on employment practices in Thailand: an examination of equity policy and practice and was published in 2000. The most recent citation comes from a 2024 study titled Class and gender influences on employment practices in Thailand: an examination of equity policy and practice . This article reached its peak citation in 2011 , with 2 citations.It has been cited in 13 different journals. Among related journals, the Management and Organization Review cited this research the most, with 2 citations. The chart below illustrates the annual citation trends for this article.
Citations used this article by year